« Graduation Marks an Ending and a New Beginning | Main | Know When to Fold 'Em »
My First Real Patient
Kendra Campbell -- I finally took my first trip to a hospital since I started med school. Several students and I went to a small hospital, located a few miles from our campus. It only had 11 beds, but almost all of them were filled with a variety of patients. I’ve spent many years in hospitals as a psychiatric technician, and as a volunteer, and even once or twice as a patient, but this was my first time in a hospital as a medical student. I actually wore my white coat and toured all the rooms with the doctor who ran the hospital. Now, I know for all you seasoned med students and physicians out there, this might not seem like a big deal, but it certainly was for me!
We first went around with the doctor from room to room, and he described each patient’s case and asked us various questions about the anatomy and pathology of their conditions. I was so thrilled to actually be applying the information that I’d previously only used to fill in multiple-choice answers on exams. I was surprised and elated to find that I could answer many of the questions that he asked! At one point, as we were examining a patient with a hydrocele of his testis, the doctor pulled out a cardboard box containing a few specimen containers. He nonchalantly opened the specimen container and pulled out a testicle that had been removed from a previous patient. As he pointed to the epididymis and described how enlarged the testicle had become, I was filled with enthusiasm! It might seem strange, but finally I could apply my knowledge of anatomy to answer real questions about real patients! Yes, I know that I am a huge dork. (But I have a suspicion that there are many of you out there that felt the same way the first time.)
After we toured the hospital, each of the students was assigned a patient to perform a full history on. This being the first time that I had taken a history from a real patient, I was a little nervous, but after introducing myself and talking to the patient for a few moments, I felt completely at ease. As I took the woman’s history, I tried to remember all the relevant questions that I had learned to ask. I found myself blanking a few times, but I remembered to ask most of the important questions.
After finishing the history, I re-joined the group, and our attending physician asked each of us to give a presentation of our patient. Since no one else would volunteer to go first, I agreed to begin. I wasn’t exactly sure how to present the case, or which order to go through the information. And I was surprised to find myself nervous when standing in front of the physician and fellow med students while giving my presentation. I know I made a million mistakes, but that was actually the point. The attending told me that I did a pretty good job, though I mixed up the order of a few items. I was so relieved once it was all over, even though I realized that I had missed a few questions that I should have asked the patient.
I’m beginning to see that my previous experience working in hospitals is quite advantageous, but I still have a lot to learn about being a good history taker. I’ve seen many histories performed, and I know all the questions to ask, but I now realize that once you’re faced with your patient, it’s easy to forget everything you know! I’m so delighted, though, about actually interacting with real patients and learning their stories. I still have very far to go, and a lot to learn, but I couldn’t be more excited about the long road ahead!
May 16, 2007 in Kendra Campbell | Permalink
Comments
yes! just as enthusiastic as i was last time.Now that im doing my clinical year...i m just having fun! love and enjoy clinical year a lott!!..way more interesting than the basic medical sciences year!..
an interesting adventure ahead!..cheers!
Posted by: valerie | May 16, 2007 10:44:04 AM
It is a delight to read of your enthusiasm!
Posted by: Jen | May 16, 2007 12:18:03 PM
its def. more fun to be out on the wards! i'm sure you'll love your third/fourth years even more than your 2nd. Also, history taking takes a while to master. So don't worry about the mistakes. I see residents forgetting to ask questions from time to time!!
Posted by: | May 16, 2007 3:59:31 PM
Well done for being brave about giving the history... I've just finished my first year on the wards, and for the first few months, I remember thinking, BOY, I never knew taking a history was THIS HARD! It's definitely not easy, but definitely comes with practice. Hope you get lots of good ward experiences!
Posted by: Grace | May 17, 2007 12:52:40 AM
my lil' sis sure is growing up! good job kevygirl :)
Posted by: jork | May 20, 2007 3:50:16 PM
Kendra
reading your article about your expereince was so exciting becasue it made think of my first exeperince in Dominica!! I too had the same wonderful emotions when I was in Dominica. I will now be graduating in June 2007 and it feels like yesterday when I arrived to Ross. If you contiune to have a postive outlook you will get soo much out of this journey. I wish you the best of luck.
Soett Ramirez-Estrada
Posted by: Soett Ramirez-Estrada | May 22, 2007 5:25:52 PM
Congratulation on your first patient! I am glad you were so excited and had a positive experience. Keep on trying!
Posted by: Wendy | May 22, 2007 8:03:50 PM
It sure is exciting. it takes a while to structure your questions and the history according to each step, but once you get a hold of it you learn to direct your questions to the problem at hand and you learn to filter out what's unnecessary.
I remember presenting my first oral exam on a patient's history, i was shaking but it went out pretty good (got a 4,5/5). now daily life doing rounds has eased me totally and everyday's an oral exam, the questions will get tougher and tougher but there's no greater satisfaction than seeing all you learned before being applied, being able to give concepts and advice to the big guys, etc., and knowing in the end you contribute- if only a little- to the well-being of someone.
Andreji
Javeriana 3rd year
Bogotá, Colombia
Posted by: Andrés Jiménez | May 23, 2007 11:00:34 AM
Clinical years of Medical School are very interesting. in my school we start the contact with patients since third grade and now I'm so happy. I've meet so many people, and many patients after being in the hospital come back to give thanks and sometimes to give presents!!
It's very exciting I love Medicine
Posted by: Claudia | May 23, 2007 11:07:27 AM
wow. I am in Australia and in my second year of my degree and I was suprised to find out you had only just seen your first patient (however i must agree with all of your excitement and ellation). When I started last year, in our first semester we were required to learn to take histories from around the 3rd week of uni. Second semester last year every week we were expected to go in pairs to take histories, and we started learning physical examination of the GI tract. This year is chest examination, and we are expected to write up and present to out tutors the history, examination and even suggest differential diagnosies: which i admit is difficult not having the full knowledge quite yet. I think the integrated way of learning is quite a good way to do it: I am being motivated through my med sci years but i also feel i am understanding what i learn a lot better because i get to see the application as i am learning: not after i have roped learned everything (i am not one much for rope learning simple because i am not very good at it).
But wonderful! Patients are fun and it is SO great to be able to sit and talk and take a history - you often learn so much more about people than their illnesses. And everytime I have to learn to do something new: a different kind of examination, or more is expected of my presentation skills - i get butterflies. But oh - it feels SO good afterwards!
:S sorry for the mini essay
Posted by: | May 23, 2007 3:57:32 PM
The best way to learn medicine is from your patients. Learn medicine at the bedside not from your Textbook!!
Posted by: PassMRCP | May 24, 2007 2:57:23 AM
i am from romania, and here, during the third year, we have "semiology" classes twice a week, and we do just that: practise taking histories. and still, when we have to do that in later years, i see very few who can ask all the relevant questions without embarrassing pauses, without helplessly looking towards colleagues for an intervention. and we always see already admitted patients, no emergencies, no life-threatening situations. it makes me worry.
Posted by: sinziana stefanescu | May 24, 2007 4:56:07 AM
Hehe reading your experience increased my enthusiasm for working harder. I'm still a pre-clinical student and hopefully after these exams (starting physiology next monday ^^) I'll qualify and start my first clinical year. Sounds like it will be hard, yet satisfying :).
Posted by: Maria Elena | May 24, 2007 7:38:14 AM
yuhuu... its great..
i can feel your spirit to become a real doctor..
It was me when i attend my first clinical year, a little bit confusing, difficult to adapt...
but now, i almost finish my clinical year or internship.. next 2 month, i will get my MD..
Keep trying, try your best....
Never give up ok...
Posted by: Edy | May 24, 2007 5:10:18 PM
wowww...it seems so interesting to be in clinical years. i still struggling for for basic medicl years...all the best to you...
n hope i'll enjoy them too....
Posted by: qila | May 24, 2007 6:07:33 PM
It,s difficult. I have a same problem like you when I get going study in hospital
I hope u ejoyed n try your best
hehehe my english very very bad ^^
Posted by: daniel | May 25, 2007 4:35:22 AM
I hope to b a bright physician for my self first & my home
Posted by: Ali HD El Mesallamy | May 25, 2007 7:35:17 AM
I am studying in Australia and where i am we are taught history taking, physical exams and presentations from first year. Although we do use simulated patients "actors", i do think this will give us a huge advantage when we do get to the wards, as i am in my second year now and already my skills have dramatically improved since last year. Even though we have these simulated patients and it is very exciting, i can not wait to interact with a real patient, with a real life and genuine corcerns.
Posted by: J. Murphy | May 26, 2007 1:49:31 AM
it was nice 2 read ur experience..
actually i'm still pre-clinical student, in the 2nd year..
at least i can imagine how's livin as clical student
gettin more enthuastic by ur experience..
gud luck n enjoy ur clinical years..
God bless...:)
Andy S. Nicholai
Makassar, Indonesia
Posted by: Andy | May 26, 2007 12:05:34 PM
nice article...i am yet in 2nd year of basic medical sciences..which is ending in this august...then from october i will start to go to hospital...this article was very informative for me...thanx kendra
Posted by: waqar | May 26, 2007 9:08:32 PM
in asking patients, they would open up better to a person who seems approachable.... so even during your clinical practice don't forget that your patients are not just object but people who have feelings and should be dealt with differently... but one way or another, if they feel that you are there to HELP!!! they would give a much better history.... i know that a lot of us in this field are always busy and always tired especially during 24-36 hrs duty that during interviewing, we seem heartless and seems in a hurry just to finish with the paperwork but a smile from you won't hurt...god bless
Posted by: ninette umpa | May 28, 2007 9:12:18 PM
rading your experience, i recall the words of a physician ...............if u know how to take history ,6o% of ur diagnosis is over.
Posted by: uttam bhatta | May 29, 2007 7:59:50 AM
hi!I'm Babara from Argentina,I'm on fifth year at med school and we see patients since 3rd year.the first time I stood in front of a patient I was really nervous, was a very stressing situation.my parents (both) are doctors too,and being there was an overwhelmed situation for me cause I was afraid of making mistakes. I realized then, that the patient was more nervous than me because he was being interviewed by "a student". the fact it´s that when we are in front of a patient we have to seem sure of us , and ask everything what we want, the patients allways say what they have. during the interview we would relax and at the end we would get a well done history, eventhough we don´t know surely it´s illness. :)
Posted by: Barbara Torrellas | Jun 2, 2007 4:28:01 PM
Hi Kendra
I liked the way u described ur experience, It's really amazing to deal with patients, but here in Iraq we practice on real patients from the beginning.. I mean the physician give us a sheet to review the questions and after an hour of discussion, we make the first try to take a history...
It seems hard and we made alot of mistakes the first time but at the end of the year u find urself almost have ur specific way of memorizing all the questions..
I am graduating next year and I think that the examinations and diagnosis are even more exciting than taking history..
Good luck with ur study
Posted by: Shayma | Jul 25, 2007 1:43:26 AM