« Finding Refuge in Medicine | Main | Which Student Groups Should You Join? »
"So, Tom, Do You See Yourself as a Nice Attending?"
Ben Ferguson -- We’re fortunate at my school to have the opportunity as students -- yes, even as freak graduate-medical student hybrids who haven’t been in medical school-proper for a few years -- to interview applicants to our medical school. For those of you who are applying to medical school in the States now or in the near future, cover your eyes for a few seconds.
THEY’RE GETTING SMARTER, AND BETTER, AND MORE QUALIFIED EVERY YEAR.
It’s true. I can’t tell whether this is a phenomenon that’s specific to my school, but it’s definitely an actual phenomenon, and it scares me.
These people I’m interviewing are so much more qualified for medical school than I ever was. Were I to apply now for admission to my medical school, I’d be laughed right into rejection (if they even bothered to send me a rejection letter). I mean, holy crap. I’ve talked to people with publications -- first-author publications, no less. I’ve met students who were varsity letter-winners and Phi Beta Kappa at the same time. I interviewed an applicant who lives in Paris and London and flies back and forth, and occasionally to New York, for consulting meetings. One student I spoke to was a TV news anchor on a children’s show as a kid, and another was a Congressional page, you know, in his spare time. I’ve chatted with at least three students who have been given university-wide awards for their academic and research prowess and several others who have done international volunteer trips to care for indigent locals. (Okay, I did this once, but it was “only” for a week, and I “only” taught a few orphaned kids some English. These folks have, for months at a time, assisted in operations and delivered medical supplies and served as translators and … the list goes on.)
So, what have I done? Let’s see, I graduated from college (by the skin of my teeth), got into a PhD program once (narrowly), and … oh, that’s pretty much it. Unlike one student I interviewed a few weeks ago, I haven’t even designed a prosthesis for one-armed water skiers for God’s sake! How would I possibly get into medical school these days?!?
While it’s disheartening and almost makes me feel even less like I deserve to be here than I already did, I continue to interview and evaluate these applicants. Why? Because I like it, because I enjoy being involved with the well-being and progress of my school, and because, especially given my situation, I feel like I can make a difference. Interviewing allows one to influence decisions about the makeup of future generations of students, and I happen to be in line to actually join those future generations in a few short mind-numbing years. For me, it’s even more important to pick people I see fitting in here, because I’m going to need to fit in with them eventually. (In fact, they could either become fellow classmates, or they could even be my residents and attendings when I return to medical school! There’s a strange thought: interviewing my future superiors for their acceptance to medical school…)
So, the moral of the story here is that, yes, brighter and brighter people are flocking to the medical profession all the time, and I’m continually impressed with them. At the same time, to all you current or future applicants out there: If you’re not a genius, do not sweat it. If you don’t have summa cum laude status from Harvard and/or Princeton, fear not. Normal peasants like me get into medical school all the time, so don’t let the success of others intimidate you or make you think you’re any less of a person simply because you haven’t accepted your prize money in Sweden yet. As far as I’m concerned, getting into medical school is as great an achievement as any these days.
October 6, 2007 in Ben Ferguson | Permalink
Comments
Thank You on behalf of students from all around the world.
True inspiration. :)
Posted by: | Oct 9, 2007 1:45:27 AM
I disagree. I feel that medical schools are letting in less and less intelligent people every year, as seen by the meteoric rise of student groups such as AMSA, who propose free healthcare for all, paid for by massive taxes, with reckless disregard for the way things work in the real world.
Posted by: Anony-mouse | Oct 9, 2007 2:28:09 PM
I am a lowly M1 but I have heard more than one attending echo Ben's sentiment about the increase in intelligence of today's applicants and their own probable inability to gain admission if they were to reapply now. If you wonder why that could be, ask yourself what other opportunity do you know of that elevates a graduate from that industry's professional training to the highest technical level of a $2+ trillion dollar industry?
As to Anony-mouse's suggestion, I would say based solely upon my experience at my school, that the reason people join student groups is based either on an area of interest (EM club) or a more utilitarian reason (the group gives out great note or test packets). I distinctly recall joining one group to get a "free" copy of Netter's.
Posted by: milsurg | Oct 9, 2007 8:30:39 PM
Ben,
I remember reading your first comment just weeks ago. I was really looking forward to reading your post since I am into research myself, and I remember feeling so (don't know how to put it) unacomplished. I am just doing minor work at my lab. So, maybe, yes, brighter people are getting into medical school. But, don't worry, I'm sure you are one of them. Keep on the good work!
Posted by: | Oct 17, 2007 3:21:56 PM
I feel even more retarded now. Haha.
Posted by: KC | Nov 20, 2007 6:23:34 PM